Cognitive Labour and Mental Load are terms you may not be familiar with, but they’re concepts that can profoundly affect relationships, particularly within the context of household management. Whether you’re male or female might also influence your understanding of these terms.
As a therapist, I’ve noticed the term “mental load” cropping up more frequently in couples counselling sessions, often as a source of conflict and frustration for the female partner.
In short, cognitive labour and mental load refer to the invisible, non-tangible tasks necessary to keep a household functioning. These tasks often reside within the minds of those living in the household and typically go unspoken—until now.
As more women have returned to the workforce over recent decades, the tasks they historically managed have become increasingly burdensome. Traditionally, men went to work, and women stayed home. But those days are long gone, and the rise of cognitive labour and mental load have arrived.
Despite shifting roles, many women continue to shoulder the mental load of managing household tasks and children’s needs, while men haven’t fully adapted to this new reality. Whether they will—or can—adjust to meet these expectations remains to be seen.
This article by the New York Times titled Why Women Do the Household Worrying, along with supporting research, breaks down the mental load into four key components: anticipate, identify, decide, and monitor. These elements highlight the complexity of what might seem like a straightforward division of tasks and responsibilities—but it’s anything but simple.
Points to Consider About Cognitive Labour and Mental Load:
- Clarity, Not Equality: The goal of mental load sharing shouldn’t be strict equality but clarity. In a culture obsessed with equality, especially between men and women, we often overlook the impracticality of achieving this in household tasks. How do you measure the weight of each task? How do you divide them? How do personality and individual skills factor in? When discussing the division of labour with couples, I find that increasing clarity about who does what is the real key to success. Aiming for equality can set a couple up for more conflict down the road, so be reasonable in your expectations.
- Gender Differences Matter: Men and women have biological and psychological differences that affect how they perceive and handle tasks. This doesn’t mean we should cling to traditional gender roles, but we must be realistic in our expectations. It’s unreasonable to expect one partner to see things the way the other does if they’ve never been taught to. Yes, they can learn, but their natural aptitude might never match their partner’s, and accepting this can bring increased connection instead of bitterness.
- Children as a Central Stressor: Many struggles with cognitive labour and mental load revolve around children. Research suggests that the mental load for women (and accompanied anxiety) often centres on family and children’s activities. Anecdotally (and in my experience in the counselling room), practical household tasks like dishes, laundry, and cleaning are now shared more equally between both partners than ever before.
- Manage Expectations: Unspoken expectations are just disappointments waiting to happen. If something in the household is bothering you, speak up. If you need to offload a task like managing bills or organizing swimming lessons, discuss it with your partner. Without clear communication, the patience and commitment to exploration and clarification and the belief in intention from the other partner you’re setting yourself up for failure and conflict—and possibly a visit to see me. :)
- Recognize Both Partners Carry an Invisible Load: Both partners carry an invisible load, and this needs to be acknowledged. Why is it invisible? What’s preventing the couple from sharing these realities? Invisible load must be recognised to include the tasks and loads that are beyond the family unit. Things like career load, volunteering, health issues, extended family dynamics etc are all examples of the broader load we all carry. Not all cognitive tasks and mental loads are equal, but making the invisible visible is crucial.
- Self-Reflection: Sometimes, the mental load we carry stems from our own standards, anxieties, role-modelling from childhood or unachievable expectations. This can lead to stress, irritability, and a need to control more, which only exacerbates the problem and leads you to blame and shame your partner. Before dividing tasks, it’s essential to engage in self-reflection. Simply splitting up tasks misses the point and is a short-term solution.
Where to from here?
Interestingly, a card game exists to help couples discuss their cognitive labour and mental load differences. I first heard about The Fairplay Card Deck on a podcast, and when the term started popping up in therapy sessions, I decided to try the card deck with my wife. Our experience was mixed. At best, it got us talking about the household tasks over coffee and a snack; at worst, it left us scratching our heads even more because the goal of equal division of labour highlighted just how complex this issue is. Many of the ‘cards’ actually overlap with each other, so equality became really frustrating.
Since that experience, my wife and I have become more attuned to what constitutes mental load for each of us–this is a win for sure. Here are two examples:
- My wife manages the grocery shopping, but we share the task of buying fruit and vegetables at the local market. She suggested a change, and rather than unilaterally deciding because it’s “her area,” we sat down and discussed our options (engaging in the broader task of problem-solving, mutual understanding, sharing ideas and growing closer).
- We recently sold our trampoline, but this job wasn’t on anyone’s specific task list. We had to discuss everything…which meant someone had to take the lead (me). The steps in getting this done were many: from getting the kids’ consent to sell it, to posting it online, negotiating the price, and coordinating the pickup etc—all of which required both of us to be on the same page. Again, we needed to engage in the deeper and more valuable asset in any relationship: connection, understanding, responsibility, listening etc.
Every relationship and family must constantly course-correct because life is ever-changing—kids grow up, work gets busy, money gets tight, etc. If you go too far down the “set and forget” path of assigning the mental load, you’re bound to create more issues and conflict.
Interestingly, this dynamic and increased mental load can lead to individuals indulging in a victim mentality, where they blame (or even shame) their partner for not picking up the slack. In reality, however, this is a relatively new social phenomenon, and getting stuck in the blame game won’t help anybody–women or men. So we need to be on the lookout for any fragment of victimhood, blame or shame, and squash them when they occur.
Instead, focus on cultivating a culture of connection, understanding, mutual sharing, vulnerability, decision-making, curiosity, and playfulness. When both partners feel confident that the other has their back, the mental load doesn’t need to be perfectly equal.
Overall, I believe the core issue with cognitive labour and mental load boils down to trust and a shared commitment to making life work together. Building a relationship where this can occur is more challenging (but also more rewarding) than simply dividing tasks. Cognitive labour and mental load are real experiences, and even though it seems like a male vs female issue, it is much broader than that–men carry an invisible burden also. While some of this is rooted in historical narratives around gender roles, the future hinges on the need for couples to create rhythms, habits, structures, and schedules that allow for regular conversations, planning, decision-making, and execution.
If you’d like to discuss the cognitive labour and mental load you or your relationship is experiencing, please contact me for an appointment.